Lloyd Price
- Jun 17, 2023

Teladoc Livongo merger: what went wrong with the 'one-stop shop for virtual care' strategy?

Exec Summary:

There are a number of reasons why the Teladoc Livongo merger did not work. Some of the most notable reasons include:

The deal was too expensive. Teladoc paid a hefty price for Livongo, which was valued at $18.5 billion. This was a significant premium to Livongo's pre-merger valuation, and it raised concerns among investors about whether Teladoc was overpaying.
The integration was difficult. The two companies had different cultures and operating models, which made it difficult to integrate them smoothly. This led to employee turnover and delays in the rollout of new products and services.
The market for digital health is maturing. When the Teladoc Livongo merger was announced in 2020, the market for digital health was still in its early stages. However, the market has matured since then, and there are now a number of other digital health companies competing with Teladoc. This has made it more difficult for Teladoc to differentiate itself from its competitors.

In addition to these reasons, the Teladoc Livongo merger was also affected by the COVID-19 pandemic. The pandemic led to a surge in demand for virtual care, but it also made it more difficult for Teladoc to integrate Livongo. This is because the pandemic forced Teladoc to focus on its core business of virtual care, and it had less time and resources to devote to integrating Livongo.

As a result of these factors, the Teladoc Livongo merger has not been the success that many people expected it to be. The company has struggled to meet its financial targets, and its stock price has fallen significantly since the merger was announced. It remains to be seen whether Teladoc will be able to turn things around, but the company faces a number of challenges in the years to come.

Corporate Development for Healthcare Technology companies in EMEA

Healthcare Technology Thought Leadership from Nelson Advisors – Market Insights, Analysis & Predictions. Visit https://www.healthcare.digital

HealthTech Corporate Development - Buy Side, Sell Side, Growth & Strategy services for Founders, Owners and Investors. Email lloyd@nelsonadvisors.co.uk

HealthTech M&A Newsletter from Nelson Advisors - HealthTech, Health IT, Digital Health Insights and Analysis. Subscribe Today! https://lnkd.in/e5hTp_xb

HealthTech Corporate Development and M&A - Buy Side, Sell Side, Growth & Strategy services for companies in Europe, Middle East and Africa. Visit www.nelsonadvisors.co.uk

Background to the Teladoc Livongo merger

The Teladoc Livongo merger was announced on August 5, 2020. The two companies were both leaders in the digital health space, and the merger was seen as a way to create a one-stop shop for virtual care.

Teladoc was a leading provider of virtual visits, while Livongo was a leader in remote patient monitoring. The merger combined Teladoc's virtual visits with Livongo's remote patient monitoring to create a comprehensive digital health platform.

The merger was valued at $18.5 billion, and it was the largest digital health deal in history at the time. The deal was completed on October 30, 2020.

The initial reaction to the merger was positive. Investors were excited about the potential of the combined company, and Teladoc's stock price rose significantly after the announcement. However, the merger has not been without its challenges.

The integration of the two companies has been difficult. Teladoc and Livongo had different cultures and operating models, which made it difficult to bring them together smoothly. This has led to employee turnover and delays in the rollout of new products and services.

In addition, the market for digital health has matured since the merger was announced. There are now a number of other digital health companies competing with Teladoc, which has made it more difficult for the company to differentiate itself from its competitors.

As a result of these challenges, Teladoc's stock price has fallen significantly since the merger was announced. The company has also struggled to meet its financial targets.

It remains to be seen whether Teladoc will be able to turn things around. However, the company has a number of strengths, including its large customer base and its strong brand name. If Teladoc can overcome the challenges it is facing, the merger could still be a success.

Here is a timeline of the Teladoc Livongo merger:

August 5, 2020: Teladoc and Livongo announce the merger.
October 30, 2020: The merger is completed.
2021: The integration of the two companies is underway.
2022: Teladoc faces challenges in the market for digital health.
2023: Teladoc's stock price falls significantly.

The future of the Teladoc Livongo merger is uncertain. However, the company has a number of strengths, and it is possible that it will be able to overcome the challenges it is facing.

History of Teladoc

Teladoc Health is a multinational telemedicine and virtual healthcare company headquartered in the United States. Primary services include telehealth, medical opinions, AI and analytics, telehealth devices and licensable platform services.

In particular, Teladoc Health uses telephone and videoconferencing software as well as mobile apps to provide on-demand remote medical care. Billed as the first and largest telemedicine company in the United States, Teladoc Health was launched in 2002 and has acquired companies such as BetterHelp in 2015, Best Doctors in 2017, and Advance Medical in 2018.

Teladoc was founded in 2002 in Dallas, Texas by G. Byron Brooks EE MD and Michael Gorton. The company's first product was a telehealth platform that allowed patients to connect with doctors via videoconferencing. Teladoc quickly grew, and by 2006 it was providing services to over 100,000 patients.

In 2013, Teladoc went public on the NYSE. The company's IPO was a success, and its stock price rose significantly in the following years. Teladoc continued to grow, and by 2017 it was providing services to over 3 million patients.

In 2017, Teladoc acquired Best Doctors, a medical consultation firm. This acquisition gave Teladoc access to Best Doctors' network of over 45,000 doctors.

In 2018, Teladoc acquired Advance Medical, a provider of home health care services. This acquisition gave Teladoc a foothold in the home health care market.

In 2020, Teladoc acquired Livongo, a leader in remote patient monitoring. This acquisition gave Teladoc a platform to provide patients with continuous care.

Current status

Teladoc is the leading provider of telemedicine in the United States. The company has over 50 million members and provides services to over 100,000 healthcare providers. Teladoc is also expanding its international presence, and it now operates in over 15 countries.

Teladoc's future looks bright. The company is well-positioned to capitalize on the growing demand for telemedicine. Teladoc is also investing in new technologies, such as AI and analytics, to improve the quality of its services.

History of Livongo

Livongo was founded in 2014 by Glen Tullman, who was the former CEO of Allscripts Healthcare Solutions. The company's mission is to "help people live healthier lives with data-driven coaching and care." Livongo's platform uses a combination of connected devices, mobile apps, and data analytics to help people with chronic conditions, such as diabetes, manage their health.

Livongo's platform includes a number of features, such as:

Connected devices: Livongo partners with a number of companies to provide connected devices to its members, such as blood glucose monitors and weight scales. These devices collect data about the user's health, which is then sent to Livongo's platform.
Mobile apps: Livongo has a mobile app that allows users to track their health data, set goals, and receive coaching from Livongo's team of experts.
Data analytics: Livongo uses data analytics to identify trends in the user's health data and to provide personalized coaching.

Livongo's platform has been shown to be effective in helping people with chronic conditions manage their health. A study published in the Journal of the American Medical Association found that Livongo's platform reduced A1C levels by 1.5% in people with diabetes.

Livongo went public in 2019 and was acquired by Teladoc in 2020. The combined company is now one of the leading providers of digital health solutions.

Here are some of the key milestones in Livongo's history:

2014: Livongo is founded by Glen Tullman.
2015: Livongo raises $355 million in Series C funding.
2016: Livongo launches its diabetes management platform.
2017: Livongo's platform is used by over 100,000 people.
2018: Livongo raises $150 million in Series D funding.
2019: Livongo goes public on the NYSE.
2020: Livongo is acquired by Teladoc.

Livongo is a leading provider of digital health solutions and is well-positioned for growth in the years to come.

Source: https://s21.q4cdn.com/672268105/files/doc_presentations/2020/09/TDOC_LVGO_Investor-Presentation-9.3.2020.pdf

What went wrong? why did the Teladoc Livongo merger fail?

There are a number of reasons why the Teladoc Livongo merger failed. Some of the most notable reasons include:

The deal was too expensive. Teladoc paid a hefty price for Livongo, which was valued at $18.5 billion. This was a significant premium to Livongo's pre-merger valuation, and it raised concerns among investors about whether Teladoc was overpaying.
The integration was difficult. The two companies had different cultures and operating models, which made it difficult to integrate them smoothly. This led to employee turnover and delays in the rollout of new products and services.
The market for digital health is maturing. When the Teladoc Livongo merger was announced in 2020, the market for digital health was still in its early stages. However, the market has matured since then, and there are now a number of other digital health companies competing with Teladoc. This has made it more difficult for Teladoc to differentiate itself from its competitors.

Here are some additional factors that may have contributed to the failure of the Teladoc Livongo merger:

The regulatory environment. The regulatory environment for digital health is complex and constantly changing. This can make it difficult for companies to integrate and launch new products and services.
The competitive landscape. The market for digital health is becoming increasingly competitive. This makes it more difficult for companies to gain market share and grow.
The economic climate. The economic climate has been challenging in recent years. This has made it more difficult for companies to raise capital and invest in growth.

Overall, there were a number of factors that contributed to the failure of the Teladoc Livongo merger. These factors include the high price of the deal, the difficulty of integrating the two companies, and the changing regulatory and competitive landscape. It remains to be seen whether Teladoc will be able to turn things around, but the company faces a number of challenges in the years to come.

Source: https://s21.q4cdn.com/672268105/files/doc_presentations/2020/09/TDOC_LVGO_Investor-Presentation-9.3.2020.pdf

What lessons can be learnt from the failed Teladoc Livongo merger?

Here are some lessons that can be learned from the failed Teladoc Livongo merger:

Do your due diligence. Before you merge with another company, make sure you do your due diligence and understand the risks involved. This includes understanding the company's financials, its culture, and its operating model.
Set clear expectations. Before you merge with another company, make sure you set clear expectations for the integration process. This includes defining roles and responsibilities, setting timelines, and communicating regularly with employees.
Be patient. Integrating two companies is a complex process that takes time. Don't expect everything to go smoothly overnight.
Be flexible. Things don't always go according to plan, so be prepared to be flexible and make adjustments as needed.
Communicate with stakeholders. Keep stakeholders informed about the merger process and the challenges and opportunities that you are facing. This will help to build trust and support for the merger.

The Teladoc Livongo merger is a cautionary tale for other companies considering mergers and acquisitions. By learning from the mistakes of Teladoc and Livongo, companies can increase their chances of success in future mergers and acquisitions.

Here are some additional lessons that can be learned from the Teladoc Livongo merger:

Don't overpay. The Teladoc Livongo merger was a $18.5 billion deal, which was a significant premium to Livongo's pre-merger valuation. This made investors question whether Teladoc was overpaying for Livongo.
Understand the market. The market for digital health is maturing, and there are now a number of other digital health companies competing with Teladoc. This makes it more difficult for Teladoc to differentiate itself from its competitors.
Be prepared for challenges. There are a number of challenges that companies face when merging with another company. These challenges include integrating the two companies' cultures, operating models, and technologies.

By learning from the mistakes of Teladoc and Livongo, companies can increase their chances of success in future mergers and acquisitions.

What is the next big merger in healthtech?

It's difficult to say for sure what the next big merger in healthtech will be, but there are a few trends that suggest some potential candidates.

One trend is the increasing focus on personalized medicine. As the ability to collect and analyze large amounts of patient data grows, there is a growing opportunity for companies to develop personalized treatments and care plans. This could lead to mergers between companies that specialize in different aspects of personalized medicine, such as data analytics, genomics, and drug development.

Another trend is the growing importance of virtual care. The COVID-19 pandemic has accelerated the adoption of virtual care, and it is likely to remain a major part of the healthcare landscape in the years to come. This could lead to mergers between companies that offer virtual care, such as Teladoc and Amwell, and companies that provide other healthcare services, such as hospitals and health insurance companies.

Finally, the healthcare industry is increasingly being disrupted by technology giants, such as Amazon, Apple, and Google. These companies have the resources and expertise to develop innovative new healthcare products and services, and they could potentially acquire smaller healthtech companies to expand their reach.

Here are some specific examples of potential mergers in healthtech:

A merger between a personalized medicine company and a drug development company. This could create a company that is able to develop and deliver personalized treatments to patients.
A merger between a virtual care company and a hospital. This could create a company that offers a seamless experience for patients, from virtual care to in-person care.
A merger between a technology giant and a healthtech company. This could create a company that has the resources and expertise to disrupt the healthcare industry.

Of course, it is impossible to say for sure which mergers will actually happen. However, the trends discussed above suggest that there is potential for some major mergers in healthtech in the years to come.